Testing five ways to connect PMRI to Scenario Builder
The tension: There was no obviously correct way to link the two tools. Tighter integration meant a smoother path but a heavier, more cluttered PMRI. Looser integration kept each tool clean but left the manager to bridge the gap themselves.
Rather than argue the options in the abstract, I built all five and put them in front of the people who would use them. Each represented a different position on that spectrum - from launching Scenario Builder as a separate destination, through to embedding scenario editing directly in the PMRI view.
Think-aloud sessions with portfolio managers narrowed five to two. What separated them wasn't preference; it was where people expected to end up after clicking. The options that survived matched the managers' existing mental model of the analysis - the ones that didn't required them to learn a new one, and that showed up immediately as hesitation.